A 2015 & 2016 Top 100 Knitting Blog!
There are a few questions I’m asked all the time: “why yarn over in reverse?” and “why use a Make 1 Loop increase?” are the most common. So hold on to your hat knitters, because now we’re diving deep into the details of knitting the Showy Decrease. Don’t worry, I’ve done most of the work for you, but I am hoping you’ll pull out your needles and yarn to swatch this with me. If knitting all the options sounds like too much work, I’ll include a swatch at the end with just the best two options for you to try.
The Vertical Showy Decrease: The only difference between the Diagonal Showy Decrease from the last post and the Vertical Showy Decrease is the position of the increase. When moved to the right of a k2tog, the increase holds the decrease in place and creates a vertical line. In this case, we don’t want the increase to show so the raised line really stands out. This swatch shows 4 options, from left to right, they are:
As you can see, the first two yarn over methods leave a gap to the right of the decrease. This was the first time I had knit options 1 and 2 side by side. I was a bit surprised to see how much gap was left even after the yo was purled closed on the next row. Let’s take a closer look.
How to Work a Make 1 Loop Increase: We never use a lifted make one increase because it would steal yarn from the Showy Decrease. Elizabeth ZImmerman’s Make 1 Loop increase is worked by grabbing a strand of yarn with your left hand adding it to the right needle. We modify it for the Vertical Showy Decrease only by twisting it counterclockwise. Turning it this way mimics the yarn over in reverse when closed. The Make 1 increase results in the neatest looking Vertical Showy Decrease because the yarn is a bit shorter than the yarn over in reverse. I find it faster to yarn over in reverse so I tend to use it unless the increase is in a location where it will be highly visible, then I use the m1 increase.
There’s one more benefit to these two options. They result in more depth. Take a closer look at the two vertical lines on the right and you’ll see that they rise higher up off the face of the stockinette fabric because there’s a real stitch there to prop them up.
Here is the full set of instructions if you’d like to swatch this for yourself. There’s a simpler version below if you only want to compare the right two options.
When you knit one of our patterns, chances are you will use both the yarn over in reverse and make 1 loop increases. The swatch below lets you try first one, then the other to see which works best for you.
YOr (yarn over in reverse)
A reverse yarn over increase is paired with a k2tog to create vertical Showy Decreases without an eyelet. When you yarn over in this direction, you can knit or purl it normally on the next round or row to close the eyelet (instead of working it through the back loop). It also prevents the rib from stretching out so don’t ignore this step).
To yarn over in reverse, wrap the yarn counterclockwise over the top of the right needle. The yarn sits like this / on the needle.
That’s it! You made it! It’s really pretty straight forward if you have yarn in your hands to try it. We’ll link back to this post in any pattern that uses this technique. You can see how we used it in the Fiftyfifty Shell published in the spring Knitty and we’re about to announce several new ways to use it as well so stay tuned!
If you’re a designer and want to incorporate these ideas into your design just send a note and I’d be happy to help.